Living With Nature

As winter quickly approaches, there has been a dramatic scene in Santa Cruz County, with the much-anticipated arrival of El Niño recently punctuated by a nearby earthquake, reminding us anew of the characteristically tenuous relationship between property owners and the natural forces that surround them.
Our social media feeds have been dominated by images such as waves crashing over the Capitola Wharf and “The West Cliff Carwash” as people continue to defy the safety warnings, fascinated by the raw power of nature on full display, with nature occasionally claiming any onlooker who gets too close.
By contrast, property losses along the coast tend to occur over a more extended period of time, like that scene in Austin Powers where Dr. Evil’s henchman gets run over in slow motion by the steamroller, which plays out at a similar pace in real life every year for oceanfront properties faced with sea level rise and the steady erosion of the California coastline.
According to a study issued last month by the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, our bluffs statewide are receding at an average rate of 1.6 inches per year. In measuring how California’s coastal cliffs changed between 2016 and 2023, they found that change was highly uneven, with some areas in Central and Northern California losing between 30 to 70 feet in a single year. Per their measurements in the most severe cliff retreat hotspots, the area of land loss over the seven-year period exceeded 800 dump-truck loads for every yard of shoreline.
The Coastal Commission’s policy of planned retreat has been a source of contention for those who own homes along the coast wanting to protect their properties and being denied permits or informed that their emergency permits issued for prior repairs were only temporary and that the protections that were installed need to be removed unless they can be approved for permanent installation, which, even if allowed, often includes costs like sand mitigation fees that can run into the millions of dollars.
This has naturally resulted in a booming industry of attorneys, engineers, contractors, architects, and adjusters who specialize in dealing with the government and insurance companies on sites that are in nature’s path, but of course, it takes time and money to fight these battles, and that needs to be measured against the romantic notion of living somewhere that is surrounded by natural beauty.
Between the forces of nature and the forces of government working against them, some experts suggest that anyone considering oceanfront property should treat it as a temporary investment with a limited lifespan, and be prepared to spend at least as much again as they paid for the property in engineering, legal costs, and fees.
All the same, the draw of nature still attracts those who are fortunate enough to be able to afford to pay the price to live so close to it, citing the philosophy that they only have so many days on this earth. And for those who choose to live in the face of such conditions, the prevailing sentiment is that living anywhere else would be less than living their best life.





Comments